Sep 10
Am i visible in Jai Ho? - Mozart
Question : Is “Jai Ho” by Mozart?
- Person 1 : Off course “Jai Ho” is composed by our Mozart(Mozart of Asia A.R.Rahman)
- Person 2 : You Know what.”Jai Ho” is composed by Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart.
- Person 1 : Hey, Are you Nuts?
- Person 2 : Hey Hey ..Be Relax..I just told that statement to provoke you..Cool Cool Cool.But I think Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart contributed some to the “Jai Ho” soundtrack…Check it out.
- Person 1 : I don’t understand your intention.
- Person 2 : Don’t you find any similarity between the above audio clip (Mozart Symphony No.40 – 1st movement) and the “jai Ho” tune.
- Person 1 : I think . . . . . . . . No
- Person 2 : Hey..I am not saying that the tune is copied.It should be a coincidence or minor case of inspiration…
- Admin : Hey hey hey.Stop stop…Lets leave the decision to world music fans…Kindly vote what do you think?
- My Poll is not good at displaying results..I will be updating the statistics now and then.As of now,
Yes – 51 votes
No – 7 votes
May be – 7 votes
i think so – 4 votes
Definitely not – 19 votes
September 10th, 2009 at 9:01 pm
Hey … IDIOT .. How u find similarities between jai ho and this piece ?? Heard this kinda tracks several hundreds of time in Bollywood …. But jai ho Is Definitely Something which stand apart from everything else … u Should chk ur ear and Hold ur tongue …Bfo Commenting anything like that … Got it ? C u in hell – Sick F***
- A Proud Rahmaniac
September 10th, 2009 at 11:23 pm
Hi Genius A.R.Rajib..I am not saying that the “Jai Ho” tune is copied..It may be a pure coincidence or inspiration or an illusion…
The views of two persons are expressed in my post..Well,you agree with Person 1..Thats it…Person 1 and Person 2 are our team members…I am the admin..Hope you got the point…I just want to know what people think about it..Thats why created a poll…Vote for what you think?Why are you getting so angry?Just take it easy man…
Please be clear about one point..Inspiration is not a crime…Even Beethoven got inspiration from Mozart’s symphony No.40 – last movement to compose his Fifth symphony – 3 rd movement…
There were many baseless allegations on “Jai Ho” at the time of announcing Oscar Awards…Hope you know about it.. That Guy Bappi Lahiri told some TV channel ARR has copied his tune(That was really stupid)…And one more guy in a forum said that Jai Ho has shades of a Pakistani song(That was funny)…If my post also falls under the same category,Vote for “definitely not” in the poll…(it will show your strong disapproval about this allegation)…Please be cool…See the results now and then to get an idea about my allegation..The poll is open for all music fans…
September 11th, 2009 at 5:02 am
I’m not finding any similarity this Mozart compo with ‘Jay Ho’…but listen to the following song…. it Salil Chowdhury loved this Mozart Compo….
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XitG1Oj0jkE
September 11th, 2009 at 10:44 am
Hey Admin, you told about that Pakistani song,right..Here it is..(from the movie “Koi Tujh Sa Kahan” released in the year 2005)…
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6VHJhkHYx3Y
after 25 seconds of this clip Note the style of composition which is somewhat similar to “Jai Ho”…
September 19th, 2009 at 11:07 pm
Yes, after hearing repeatedly a music follower who has some knowledge abt WCM and other musical forms will come to the conclusion that “Jai Ho” is definitly inspired by this piece of Mozart especially 1st movement, ARR has a stamp that he very cleverly embeds other compositions and it is very hard to differentiate the original and inspired…slumdog has another song inspired by LP’s “Choli ke peeche”, is it crime to inspire ?
January 2nd, 2010 at 8:13 pm
AR often gets inspired
January 5th, 2010 at 10:16 pm
‘Jai Ho’ songs prelude will be more similar Tamil song” Ella Pugazhum Iraivan oruvannukae” Obviously both are 4m Rahman. But then why does many a fan of Rahman are so arrogant. What is wrong in inspiring. I mean Mozart’s song would be known even to a kid who tries to learn keyboard. So der is a many a chance for Rahman to get inspired. Chill out guys…
January 26th, 2010 at 1:27 pm
Good Find. Surely Inspired!